Anthony Garcia has been sentenced to four years in prison on one count and five years on another count for tainting supermarket yogurt with his own semen.

Prosecutors are now seeking harsher punishment for Garcia. Due to a lack of criminal history, he is being treated as more like a first time offender. Prosecutors think that the crime he has committed warrants much harsher punishment.

“Such categorization does not fairly reflect the far more disturbing portrait” of Garcia, prosecutors wrote in their January 25 motion for an “upward departure.”

One woman said the yogurt “tasted funny” so she did not finish the sample. Another victim reported that the yogurt she ate was “gross.” A third woman reported that the yogurt “did not taste good and wanted to spit it out, but she could not find a trash can to do so.”

More From 98.7 The Bomb